Vagueness and Contradiction

Vagueness and Contradiction

3.67 (6 ratings by Goodreads)
By (author) 

Free delivery worldwide

Available. Expected delivery to the United States in 9-12 business days.

Not ordering to the United States? Click here.


Did Buddha become a fat man in one second? Is there a tallest short giraffe?

Epistemicists answer 'Yes!' They believe that any predicate that divides things divides them sharply. They solve the ancient sorites paradox by picturing vagueness as a kind of ignorance. The alternative solutions are radical. They either reject classical theorems or inference rules or reject our common sense view of what can exist. Epistemicists spare this central portion of our web of belief by challenging peripheral intuitions about the nature of language.
So why is this continuation of the status quo so incredible? Why do epistemicists themselves have trouble believing their theory?
In Vagueness and Contradiction Roy Sorensen traces our incredulity to linguistic norms that build upon our psychological tendencies to round off insignificant differences. These simplifying principles lead to massive inconsistency, rather like the rounding off errors of calculators with limited memory. English entitles speakers to believe each 'tolerance conditional' such as those of the form 'If n is small, then n + 1 is small.' The conjunction of these a priori beliefs entails absurd
conditionals such as 'If 1 is small, then a billion is small.' Since the negation of this absurdity is an a priori truth, our a priori beliefs about small numbers are jointly inconsistent. One of the tolerance conditionals, at the threshold of smallness, must be an analytic falsehood that we are compelled to
regard as a tautology.
Since there are infinitely many analytic sorites arguments, Sorensen concludes that we are obliged to believe infinitely many contradictions. These contradictions are not specifically detectable. They are ineliminable, like the heat from a light bulb. Although the light bulb is not designed to produce heat, the heat is inevitably produced as a side-effect of illumination.
Vagueness can be avoided by representational systems that make no concession to limits of perception, or memory, or testimony. But quick and rugged representational systems, such as natural languages, will trade 'rationality' for speed and flexibility.
Roy Sorensen defends epistemicism in his own distinctive style, inventive and amusing. But he has some serious things to say about language and logic, about the way the world is and about our understanding of it.
show more

Product details

  • Paperback | 208 pages
  • 138 x 216 x 14mm | 269g
  • Clarendon Press
  • Oxford, United Kingdom
  • English
  • Revised ed.
  • 019927116X
  • 9780199271160
  • 905,420

Table of contents

Introduction ; 1. Absolute Borderline Cases ; 2. Intellectual Embarrassment without Vagueness ; 3. Forced Analytical Errors ; 4. Inconsistent Machines ; 5. Sainsbury's Spectra and the Penrose Triangle ; 6. Does Apriority Agglomerate? ; 7. Analytic Sorites and the Cheshire Cat ; 8. Believing the Impossible ; 9. Reason Demands Belief in Infinitely Many Contradictions ; 10. The Viral Theory of Inconsistency ; 11. Truthmaker Gaps ; References, Index
show more

Review quote

Review from previous edition Sorensen's book is well worth reading. His version of epistemicism is a more robust version than Williamson's, and his arguments for being rationally compelled towards inconsistency are important and interesting in themselves ... Anyone working in the philosophy of language will benefit from reading the book; and anyone working on the paradoxes must read the book. I strongly recommend the book as a central text for classes in the
philosophy of language (at either the undergraduate or graduate level). * J C Beall, Notre Dame Philosophical Reviews *
show more

Rating details

6 ratings
3.67 out of 5 stars
5 17% (1)
4 33% (2)
3 50% (3)
2 0% (0)
1 0% (0)
Book ratings by Goodreads
Goodreads is the world's largest site for readers with over 50 million reviews. We're featuring millions of their reader ratings on our book pages to help you find your new favourite book. Close X