Decision : How the Supreme Court Decides Cases

By (author) 

Free delivery worldwide

Available. Dispatched from the UK in 4 business days
When will my order arrive?


Decision days appear to outsiders as among the most dramatic events on the Supreme Court calendar. One thinks, for instance, of Chief Justice Earl Warren, reading the unanimous opinion in Brown v. Board of Education in a courtroom pervaded by tension. But the real drama of Brown and other Supreme Court cases may well have been what went on behind the scenes. Rarely do the arguments of counsel-brilliant though they may appear to the courtroom audience-dictate the decision in an important Supreme Court case. Rather, the crucial argument in a case takes place privately among the Justices after the public hearing. Decision provides a unique behind-the-scenes look at the Supreme Court and how its Justices decide cases. Distinguished author Bernard Schwartz, described by The New York Times as "one of the nation's leading legal scholars," uses confidential conference notes, draft opinions, memoranda, letters, and interviews to tell what really goes on behind the red velour curtain. Cases and anecdotes, woven into deft discussions of the Justices and how they function, provide unmatched insights into our high tribunal. We read of the conferences where the Justices cast their votes, the decisions as to who will write opinions (one of the most critical choices made by the Chief Justice), the often extensive give and take of the draft opinion, and the intense lobbying between Justices that influences vote changes (it was Chief Justice Earl Warren's pressure on Justice Reed in Brown that made the final vote unanimous). Schwartz focuses on the Warren, Burger, and Rehnquist courts, providing not just vivid portraits of the Chief Justices themselves, but also profiles of many Associate Justices in action-including Felix Frankfurter, Byron R. White, Sandra Day O'Connor, William J. Brennan, Thurgood Marshall, and John Paul Stevens. And Schwartz includes an eye-opening discussion of the expanding role of the Justices' clerks, revealing that they are no longer merely a "staff of assistants." Instead, they have evolved into a sort of "Junior Supreme Court," which performs a major part of the judicial role-including the writing of opinions-delegated by the Constitution to the Justices themselves. Decision gives readers a privileged look at countless cases throughout the Court's history, from the Dred Scott decision to Miranda v. Arizona to the controversial decision in Roe v. Wade to United States v. Nixon (the Watergate tapes case). Highly readable, yet written with impeccable scholarship, Decision shows the Justices in action as never before. Everything you wanted to know about the Supreme Court and were afraid to ask is here, in a revealing work on the institution that has had such an impact on our law and our more

Product details

  • Paperback | 288 pages
  • 136.1 x 204 x 14.2mm | 222.26g
  • Oxford University Press Inc
  • New York, United States
  • English
  • Reprint
  • black & white illustrations
  • 0195118006
  • 9780195118001

Review quote

Arguably the leading Supreme Court scholar of the day. * Supreme Court Historical Society Quarterly * Privy to heretofore unrevealed internal memoranda, Professor Bernard Schwartz has produced a remarkable scholarly analysis of Supreme Court practice and the thought processes of past and present justices who have been at the helm of our nation's judiciary. * Stanley Mosk, Justice, Supreme Court of California * While Supreme Court decisions determine the rights of all individuals and the powers of all government officials, the Court's deliberations and actions that lead to these vitally important decisions are largely shielded from public view. By shedding valuable light on the Court's behind-the-scenes workings, Decision should enrich public understanding and support of our constitutional liberties and the Justices who uphold them. * Nadine Strossen, President, American Civil Liberties Union, and Professor of Law, New York Law School * Shows that the justices...make law through a much more collaborative and less individualistic process than is generally assumed.... Reading about the justices' foibles and personality conflicts is all the more entertaining given the veil of secrecy behind which they normally work.... Thoughtful and illuminating. * Kirkus Reviews * This fascinating book shows how the major decisions of the Supreme Court came to be, including Roe v. Wade.... In all, a terrific primer on the Supreme Court, the true lawgivers of the republic. * Booklist * Decision combines the scholar's meticulous research with the journalist's instinct for reporting. A reader feels like a witness to the exercise of the best legal minds on the Court (and of those that sometimes fell short). In the end, this book is a reassuring picture of those who wield unreviewable power. * Marcia Coyle, The New York Times Book Review *show more

About Bernard Schwartz

Bernard Schwartz, the Chapman Distinguished Professor of Law at the University of Tulsa, has written the definitive judicial biography of Chief Justice Earl Warren, as well as many other books on the Supreme Court, including A History of the Supreme Court, The Reins of Power: A Constitutional History of the United States, and The Unpublished Opinions of the Rehnquist more